Yankee Candle vs Village Candle: Which is Better?


When thinking of candles, one of the first companies to pop into your thoughts is most likely going to be Yankee Candle. While not as wildly popular, Village Candle is a company that you should be thinking of, too, when you think of candles. Both of these companies offer you high quality candles but which one of these is going to give you the better candle?

Out of the two companies, you’ll find that Yankee Candle is going to provide their customers with the best quality candles while Village Candles are going to be a better option if you’re looking for budget candles.

While the products from these companies release similar products, there are some differences that will make it easy to decide which company you want to purchase from.

First, we’ll take a look at the similarities between the products distributed by both companies and then we’ll discuss the differences. By taking in these similarities and differences, it’ll be easy to see that Yankee Candle produces and distributes the better candles.

Yankee Candle vs Village Candle

The Similarities between Candles from Yankee Candle and Village Candle

When you look at Yankee Candle and Village Candle, you may notice that they look very similar to each other. Both companies use similar styled jars, making it easy to mistake one brand for the other if you don’t look at the labels close enough. To make them look even more similarly, Village Candle brandishes their jars with labels that look near identical to labels on several of Yankee Candle’s jars. Both jars display a beautiful picture representing the fragrance as well as similar fonts that make them look so similar.

Another similarity between these two companies is the composition of the candles. Both companies use a premium-grade paraffin wax to ensure that their customers are getting the strongest scent throw out of their candles. These companies also both use fragrance oils to create the wonderful scents in their candles. By using fragrance oils and paraffin wax, these companies are making candles that are both affordable and give off a strong scent throw.

Both of these companies provide their customers with a candle that can double as a decoration. They both use apothecary jars to house their candles, which can be decorations themselves. The colorful dyes used for the candle wax helps create a candle that works as a great decoration, too. By adding a label with a beautiful picture, these companies are ensuring that their customers are getting a great decorative piece on top of a great fragrance.

One more notable similarity between the two candle companies is the style of jars they use. The iconic jars put out by both companies are without a doubt the apothecary jars, which come in a few different sizes. While these are the type of jar you think of when Yankee Candle or Village Candle comes to mind, they aren’t the only type of jar being used.

Both companies use tumblers that come with metal lids, which is great for someone that is looking for a candle that isn’t going to stand out too much. Both companies also have votive candles to choose from that don’t come in a jar but are great for using in candle holders or as decoration pieces.

The Differences between the Candles from Yankee Candle and Village Candle

Now that we know a few of the similarities between these two popular brands, we now get to dive into the differences between these two companies. While these candles appear to be similar, they actually have several differences that set the two companies apart.

Sizes

One notable difference between the two companies is the amount of size options the customers are provided with. Village Candle provides their customers with eight different sizes. The sizes they offer are:

  • 1.25 ounces
  • 3.25 ounces
  • 7.25 ounces
  • 9.25 ounces
  • 13.75 ounces
  • 14 ounces
  • 19 ounces
  • 21.25 ounces.

While it’s not a huge difference, Yankee Candle does offer a wider range of sizes than Village Candle does, giving their customers ten different sizes to choose from. The sizes Yankee Candle offers are:

  • 0.35 ounces
  • 1.3 ounces
  • 1.75 ounces
  • 3.7 ounces
  • 7 ounces
  • 12 ounces
  • 14.5 ounces
  • 18 ounces
  • 19.5 ounces
  • 22 ounces

Even though Yankee Candle only has two more size options than Village Candle, it’s worth noting because even with the small difference, customers are still getting a bigger variety of products. By giving more size options, a company is giving their customers even more choices and will fit better to the needs and preferences of more people.

Fragrances

The amount of fragrances is another difference worth mentioning. One of the biggest differences in the fragrances is the amount each company offers. Yankee Candle, yet again, offers a wider range of options than Village Candle does with over 600 different fragrances to choose from. While Village Candle does have an impressive amount of fragrances, their variety doesn’t even closely compare to what Yankee Candle has to offer.

Another difference is the way the fragrances are created. Yankee Candle’s candles have a layered fragrance, which means that you’ll pick up different notes as you continue to smell your candle. For example, in their lilac blossoms candle, you’ll get these notes:

  • Top: Dewy greens, water lily, bergamot
  • Mid: Hyacinth, lilac petals, tulip bulbs
  • Base: Cedar leaf, moss, vetiver

With Village Candles, on the other hand, you’ll have a mixture of fragrances to create the name fragrance, but it’s not going to be a layered effect like in Yankee Candle candles. Looking at a fragrance similar to lilac blossoms, Village Candle has a fragrance called spring lilac. This fragrance is made up of a mixture of fresh lilac, dewy petals, and white hyacinth. These fragrances are blended together instead of layered in the candle, giving you every fragrance at once.

The scent throw is another topic that should be discussed while we’re talking about fragrances. Both of these companies offer fragrances with strong scent throws but the scent throw from Yankee Candle candles is stronger and has more of an authentic feel to it than Village Candle candles do.

Price

The price difference is where Village Candle thrives. Village Candle is a great choice for someone who is looking for a good quality candle but doesn’t want to fork out a ton of money to obtain it. Their large apothecary candles, which are 21.25 ounces, can be bought for $20. Yankee Candles large apothecary candles, which are 22 ounces, cost a bit more at $30 a candle.

The $10 difference between the two candles is substantial when you compare the small difference in the amount of wax used in the two candles. It’s hard to argue that .75 ounces of wax is worth the price difference you’re paying, but you also have to take into consideration the better fragrances when figuring out which to buy.

Regardless of other candle factors, when deciding to buy a candle, it can be incredibly tempting to purchase the cheaper candle. If you choose to purchase Village Candle over Yankee Candle, you won’t be disappointed with the product because Village Candle does genuinely put out good quality candles.

And the Winner is…

Both Yankee Candle and Village Candle are great contenders and put up a good battle between each other. At the end of it, though, Yankee Candle is going to come out on top. Their wide range of sizes and their extensive lines of fragrances are just a few reasons as to why Yankee Candle is the superior brand that gives you more variety and better products.

While Village Candle does offer cheaper candles, that are still good quality and a great product, this factor doesn’t hold up against all of the benefits that Yankee Candle has compared to Village Candle.

No matter what company you choose to buy from, you’re going to have a great product, but you’re going to have the best experience if you buy from Yankee Candle.

Grace Young

I love candles! I have personally tried over 100 brands of candles. The total burn time of these candles is over 5000 hours. I also talk about essential oil diffusers and reed diffusers. Essential oil diffusers and diffusers are also an important part of the scent in my home.

Recent Posts